1989 Season
| Position | Name | Team |
| Pitcher | Randy Baier | Tilden Tigers |
| Pitcher | Dave Hepfler | Jim Falls Sturgeons |
| Catcher | Paul McIlquham | Jim Falls Sturgeons |
| 1st Base | Mike Thalacker | Chippewa Falls Lumberjacks |
| 2nd Base | John Davenport | Eau Claire Pioneers |
| 3rd Base | Scott Schemenauer | Jim Falls Sturgeons |
| Shortstop | John Plesac | Lafayette Lakers |
| Outfield | Ben Gardow | Tilden Tigers |
| Outfield | Scott Hughes | Augusta Athletics |
| Outfield | Dan Pearson | Chippewa Falls Lumberjacks |
| Utility | Steven Nelson | Chippewa Falls Lumberjacks |
| Sportsmanship Award | Bloomer Merchants |
1988 Season
| Position | Name | Team |
| Pitcher | Russ Nelson | Jim Falls Sturgeons |
| Pitcher | Steve Nelson | Chippewa Falls Lumberjacks |
| Catcher | Paul McIlquham | Jim Falls Sturgeons |
| 1st Base | Jay Johnson | Hallie Eagles |
| 2nd Base | John Plesac | Lafayette Lakers |
| 3rd Base | Terry Spaeth | Chippewa Falls Lumberjacks |
| Shortstop | Rick Rubenzer | Jim Falls Sturgeons |
| Outfield | Pat Olson | Lafayette Lakers |
| Outfield | Randy Rubenzer | Jim Falls Sturgeons |
| Outfield | Dan Pearson | Chippewa Falls Lumberjacks |
| Utility | Dave Hepfler | Jim Falls Sturgeons |
| Sportsmanship Award | Jim Falls Sturgeons & Tilden Tigers |
1987 Season
| Position | Name | Team |
| Pitcher | Jim Hoepner | Chippewa Falls Lumberjacks |
| Pitcher | Dwayne Reiter | Hallie Eagles |
| Catcher | Paul McIlquham | Jim Falls Sturgeons |
| 1st Base | Butch Woodford | Lafayette Indians |
| 2nd Base | Chuck Hall | Chippewa Falls Lumberjacks |
| 3rd Base | Kevin Schreiner | Tilden Tigers |
| Shortstop | Jim Spaeth | Chippewa Falls Lumberjacks |
| Outfield | Todd Harings | Cadott Red Sox |
| Outfield | Chico LaBarbera | Hallie Eagles |
| Outfield | Randy Schemenauer | Jim Falls Saints |
| Utility | Scott Stuckert | Bloomer Merchants |
| Sportsmanship Award | Jim Falls Sturgeons & Cadott Red Sox |
1986 Season
| Position | Name | Team |
| Pitcher | Todd Bohl | Bloomer Merchants |
| Pitcher | Bill Schoch | Tilden Tigers |
| Catcher | Steve Nelson | Jim Falls Saints |
| 1st Base | Walt Henning | Hallie Eagles |
| 2nd Base | Greg Kirkmeyer | Tilden Tigers |
| 3rd Base | Mike Pearson | Eau Claire Pioneers |
| Shortstop | Scott Stuckert | Bloomer Merchants |
| Outfield | Dan LaVelle | Tilden Tigers |
| Outfield | Dan Pearson | Chippewa Falls Lumberjacks |
| Outfield | Mike Yakesh | Bloomer Merchants |
| Utility | Randy Rubenzer | Jim Falls Sturgeons |
| Sportsmanship Award | Bloomer Merchants |
1985 Season
| Position | Name | Team |
| Pitcher | Reggie Franz | Tilden Tigers |
| Pitcher | Jim Hoepner | Chippewa Falls Lumberjacks |
| Catcher | Gerry Hopener | Chippewa Falls Lumberjacks |
| 1st Base | Jeff Zwiefelhofer | Tilden Tigers |
| 2nd Base | Paul McIlquham | Jim Falls Sturgeons |
| 3rd Base | Terry Spaeth | Chippewa Falls Lumberjacks |
| Shortstop | Joey Wagner | Cadott Red Sox |
| Outfield | Randy Rhude | Hallie Eagles |
| Outfield | Dan Pearson | Chippewa Falls Lumberjacks |
| Outfield | Bill Schoch | Tilden Tigers |
| Utility | Randy Rubenzer | Jim Falls Sturgeons |
| Utility | Mike Goebel | Cornell Oilers |
| Sportsmanship Award | Cornell Oilers | |
1984 Season
| Position | Name | Team |
| Pitcher | Reggie Franz | Tilden Tigers |
| Pitcher | Jim Hoepner | Chippewa Falls Lumberjacks |
| Pitcher (Tie in voting) | Tim Schuring | Hallie Eagles |
| Catcher | Steve Nelson | Jim Falls Saints |
| 1st Base | Tim Prince | Bloomer Merchants |
| 2nd Base | Jeff Rhude | Hallie Eagles |
| 3rd Base | Kevin Schreiner | Tilden Tigers |
| Shortstop | Chuck Hall | Chippewa Falls Lumberjacks |
| Outfield | Jeff Lawler | Lafayette Indians |
| Outfield | Dan Lenczner | Tilden Tigers |
| Outfield | Randy Rubenzer | Jim Falls Sturgeons |
| Utility | Dan McConville | Cadott Red Sox |
| Sportsmanship Award | Bloomer Merchants | |
1983 Season
| Position | Name | Team |
| Pitcher | Jim Bobb | Lafayette Indians |
| Pitcher | Jim Hoepner | Chippewa Falls Lumberjacks |
| Catcher | Duane Ruff | Cadott Red Sox |
| 1st Base | Ron Stewart | Bloomer Merchants |
| 2nd Base | John Bachmeier | Lafayette Indians |
| 3rd Base | Stan Prince | Chippewa Falls Lumberjacks |
| Shortstop | Denny Ruff | Cadott Red Sox |
| Outfield | Jeff Lawler | Lafayette Indians |
| Outfield | Ken Poppe | Cadott Red Sox |
| Outfield | Randy Rubenzer | Jim Falls Sturgeons |
| Utility | Ron Thalacker | Chippewa Falls Lumberjacks |
| Sportsmanship Award | Jim Falls Sturgeons | |
1982 Season
| Position | Name | Team |
| Pitcher | Rick Goettl | Cadott Red Sox |
| Pitcher | Bill Schoch | Tilden Tigers |
| Catcher | Arnie Bowe | Tilden Tigers |
| 1st Base | Ron Stewart | Bloomer Merchants |
| 2nd Base | Ron Thalacker | Lafayette Indians |
| 3rd Base | Mike Freagon | Cadott Red Sox |
| Shortstop | Denny Ruff | Cadott Red Sox |
| Outfield | Jeff Lawler | Lafayette Indians |
| Outfield | Mike Huettl | Lafayette Lakers |
| Outfield | Scott Miller | Lafayette Lakers |
| Utility | Jeff Couey | Cadott Red Sox |
| Sportsmanship Award | Bloomer Merchants | |
1981 Season
| Position | Name | Team |
| Pitcher | Rick Goettl | Cadott Red Sox |
| Pitcher | Jim Hoepner | Chippewa Falls Lumberjacks |
| Catcher | Duane Ruff | Cadott Red Sox |
| 1st Base | Jeff Couey | Cadott Red Sox |
| 2nd Base | Lyle Sonnentag | Cadott Red Sox |
| 3rd Base | Walt Henning | Hallie Eagles |
| Shortstop | Denny Ruff | Cadott Red Sox |
| Outfield | Jeff Lawler | Lafayette Indians |
| Outfield | Ken Smetana | Bloomer Merchants |
| Outfield | Gerald Nelson | Jim Falls Saints |
| Utility | Tim Seichter | Lafayette Indians |
| Sportsmanship Award | Not recognized | |
1980 Season
| Position | Name | Team |
| Pitcher | Tom Dachel | Tilden Tigers |
| Pitcher | Denny Ruff | Cadott Red Sox |
| Catcher | Arnie Bowe | Tilden Tigers |
| Catcher | Duane Ruff | Cadott Red Sox |
| 1st Base | Jeff Couey | Cadott Red Sox |
| 2nd Base | Pete Sokup | Cooks Valley Hayshakers |
| 3rd Base | Jeff Zwiefelhofer | Tilden Tigers |
| Shortstop | Joe Vavra | Lafayette Indians |
| Outfield | Pat Prince | Cooks Valley Hayshakers |
| Outfield | Bob Woodcock | Lafayette Indians |
| Outfield | Gerald Nelson | Jim Falls Saints |
| Utility | Jim Stuckert | Bloomer Merchants |
| Sportsmanship Award | Jim Falls Saints | |