1979 Season
| Position | Name | Team |
| Pitcher | Tom Dachel | Tilden Tigers |
| Pitcher | Jim Hoepner | Lafayette Lakers |
| Catcher | Arnie Bowe | Tilden Tigers |
| 1st Base | Jeff Couey | Cadott Red Sox |
| 2nd Base | Doug Rykal | Cadott Red Sox |
| 3rd Base | Gary Rubenzer | Bloomer Merchants |
| Shortstop | Joe Vavra | Lafayette Indians |
| Outfield | Jeff Lawler | Lafayette Indians |
| Outfield | Gary Lazarz | Hallie Eagles |
| Outfield | Butch Woodford | Lafayette Lakers |
| Utility | Dave Hepfler | Hallie Eagles |
| Sportsmanship Award | Bloomer Merchants | |
1978 Season
| Position | Name | Team |
| Pitcher | Dave DeMask | Bloomer Blackhawks |
| Pitcher | Greg Lueder | Lafayette Indians |
| Catcher | Howie Vavra | Lafayette Indians |
| 1st Base | Bud Bowe | Tilden Tigers |
| 2nd Base | Dave Guite | Lafayette Indians |
| 3rd Base | Ken Steinmetz | Lafayette Lakers |
| Shortstop | John Blackwell | Colfax Merchants |
| Outfield | Jeff Couey | Cadott Red Sox |
| Outfield | Tom Drehmel | Cadott Red Sox |
| Outfield | Don Holcomb | Lafayette Lakers |
| Sportsmanship Award | Hallie Eagles | |