The CRBL managers have voted and selected the 2021 CRBL All-League awards. The Osseo Merchants were awarded the most All-League selections with five.
| Position | Player | Team |
|---|---|---|
| Pitcher | Levi Schaller | Chippewa Falls LumberJacks |
| Pitcher | Curtis Dachel | Bloomer Woodticks |
| Pitcher | Luke Eide* | Osseo Merchants |
| Catcher | Nolan Hutzler | Chippewa Falls LumberJacks |
| 1st Base | Nate Hayes | Chippewa Falls LumberJacks |
| 2nd Base | Nathan Kent* | Eau Claire Bears |
| 3rd Base | Nolan Baier* | Tilden Tigers |
| Shortstop | Jesse Brockman | Osseo Merchants |
| Outfield | Jon Schoch | Tilden Tigers |
| Outfield | Jordan Steinmetz | Tilden Tigers |
| Outfield | Mitch Voller | Eau Claire Cavaliers |
| Utility | Tyler Gray | Eau Claire Rivermen |
| DH | Nolan Matson* | Osseo Merchants |
| MVP | Luke Eide | Osseo Merchants |
| ROY | Mitch Voller | Eau Claire Cavaliers |
| Sportmanship Award | Cadott Red Sox | |
| Manager of the Year | Luke Anderson | Osseo Merchants |
- Within the thirteen individuals selected for 2021 All-CRBL awards, there were eight first year winners, three repeat winners from 2019, and five individuals who had previously won an All-CRBL award.
- With his 6th All-CRBL award, the Eau Claire Rivermen’s Tyler Gray is now tied for 15th all-time in that category.
- The all-time leader in All-CRBL selections is the Eau Claire Rivermen’s Andy Niese with 12.
Honorable Mention All-CRBL
| Team | Player | Position |
|---|---|---|
| Beef River Bullfrogs | Brandon Jaenke | Pitcher |
| Bloomer Woodticks | Connor Stoik | Shortstop |
| Cadott Red Sox | Zac Merritt | Shortstop |
| Chippewa Falls LumberJacks | Chip Blair | DH |
| Eau Claire Bears | Blake Johnson | DH |
| Eau Claire Cavaliers | Anthony Pogodzinski | 1st Base |
| Eau Claire Rivermen | James Davis | Utility |
| Jim Falls Sturgeons | Ryan Krumenauer | Utility |
| Osseo Merchants | Joe Zawacki | 1st Base |
| Tilden Tigers | Cole Zwiefelhofer | Utility |
| Whitehall Wolves | Jordan Hauser | Catcher |
- Of the eleven individuals recognized with an Honorable Mention All-CRBL award, eight were first time winners and three were previous winners.
- Tyler Gray’s six Honorable Mention Awards are a CRBL record.
CRBL Gold Glove Awards
For the first time in CRBL history, the league officers and managers have selected Gold Gloves. This represents each teams best defensive player, regardless of position.
| Team | Player | Position |
|---|---|---|
| Beef River Bullfrogs | Taylor Rathke | 2nd Base |
| Bloomer Woodticks | Jake Malinowski | Center Field |
| Cadott Red Sox | Shawn Sedlacek | Left Field |
| Chippewa Falls LumberJacks | Jake Varsho | Shortstop |
| Eau Claire Bears | Alex Jenkins | Catcher |
| Eau Claire Cavaliers | Jaxon Vance | Shortstop |
| Eau Claire Rivermen | Sawyer Sturz | Shortstop |
| Jim Falls Sturgeons | Tristin Hable | Center Field |
| Osseo Merchants | Todd Wienkes | Catcher |
| Tilden Tigers | Jordan Steinmetz | Center Field |
| Whitehall Wolves | Jordan Hauser | Catcher |