2019 Season
| Position | Name | Team |
| Pitcher | Logan Boettcher* | Osseo Merchants |
| Pitcher | Curtis Dachel | Bloomer Woodticks |
| Pitcher | Paul Petit | Eau Claire Cavaliers |
| Catcher | Jordan Hauser | Whitehall Wolves |
| 1st Base | Tom Mewhorter | Eau Claire Cavaliers |
| 2nd Base | Nate Pronchinske | Whitehall Wolves |
| 3rd Base | Tyler Herman | Eau Claire Cavaliers |
| Shortstop | Jesse Brockman | Osseo Merchants |
| Outfield | Ryan Freitag* | Osseo Merchants |
| Outfield | Jordan Wilson | Eau Claire Cavaliers |
| Outfield | Jon Schoch | Tilden Tigers |
| Utility | Cole Zwiefelhofer | Tilden Tigers |
| DH | Sam Janni* | Eau Claire Bears |
| MVP | Ryan Freitag | Osseo Merchants |
| ROY | Jordan Hauser | Whitehall Wolves |
| Sportsmanship Award | Cadott Red Sox | |
| Manager of the Year | Chevy Tollefson | Eau Claire Bears |
* Unanimous selection
2018 Season
| Position | Name | Team |
| Pitcher | Alex Byom | Whitehall Wolves |
| Pitcher | Curtis Dachel | Bloomer Woodticks |
| Pitcher | Jake Peterson | Osseo Merchants |
| Catcher | Andy Niese | Eau Claire Rivermen |
| 1st Base | Tom Mewhorter | Eau Claire Cavaliers |
| 2nd Base | Alex Ruf | Tilden Tigers |
| 3rd Base | Jimmy Anderson | Beef River Bullfrogs |
| Shortstop | Corey Poirer | Bloomer Woodticks |
| Outfield | Ryan Freitag | Osseo Merchants |
| Outfield | Todd Lasher | Beef River Bullfrogs |
| Outfield | Jon Schoch | Tilden Tigers |
| Utility | Tyler Gray | Eau Claire Rivermen |
| DH | Sam Janni | Eau Claire Bears |
| MVP | Alex Byom | Whitehall Wolves |
| ROY | Paul Petit | Eau Claire Cavaliers |
| Sportsmanship Award | Cadott Red Sox | |
| Manager of the Year | Sam Elling | Bloomer Woodticks |
2017 Season
| Position | Name | Team |
| Pitcher | Alex Byom | Whitehall Wolves |
| Pitcher | Jake Peterson | Osseo Merchants |
| Pitcher | Chevy Tollefson | Eau Claire Bears |
| Catcher | Max Ferguson | Whitehall Wolves |
| 1st Base | Tom Mewhorter | Eau Claire Cavaliers |
| 2nd Base | Sam Waters | Osseo Merchants |
| 3rd Base | Jimmy Anderson | Beef River Bullfrogs |
| Shortstop | Jesse Brockman | Osseo Merchants |
| Outfield | Ryan Freitag | Osseo Merchants |
| Outfield | Jon Schoch | Tilden Tigers |
| Outfield | Jordan Wilson | Eau Claire Cavaliers |
| Utility | James Gilbertson | Augusta Athletics |
| DH | Andy Niese | Eau Claire Rivermen |
| MVP | Ryan Freitag | Osseo Merchants |
| ROY | Dalton Hutton | Eau Claire Rivermen |
| Sportsmanship Award | Osseo Merchants | |
| Manager of the Year | Garrett Nix | Osseo Merchants |
2016 Season
| Position | Name | Team |
| Pitcher | Logan Boettcher | Osseo Merchants |
| Pitcher | Alex Byom | Whitehall Wolves |
| Pitcher | Chevy Tollefson | Eau Claire Bears |
| Catcher | Nolan Matson | Osseo Merchants |
| 1st Base | Jake Lindberg | Eau Claire Bears |
| 2nd Base | Kevin Christorf | Stanley Slammers |
| 3rd Base | James Gilbertson | Augusta Athletics |
| Shortstop | Drew Steinmetz | Tilden Tigers |
| Outfield | Ryan Freitag | Osseo Merchants |
| Outfield | Todd Lasher | Beef River Bullfrogs |
| Outfield | Austin LeMay | Tilden Tigers |
| Utility | Mitch DeGrasse | Eau Claire Bears |
| DH | Randy Gustafson | Stanley Slammers |
| MVP | Alex Byom | Whitehall Wolves |
| ROY | Nolan Matson | Osseo Merchants |
| Sportsmanship Award | Jim Falls Sturgeons | |
| Manager of the Year | Garret Nix | Osseo Merchants |
2015 Season
| Position | Name | Team |
| Pitcher | Alex Byom | Whitehall Wolves |
| Pitcher | Matt Lunde | Eau Claire Bears |
| Pitcher | Jake Peterson | Osseo Merchants |
| Catcher | Sam Janni | Eau Claire Bears |
| 1st Base | Brian Menard | Eau Claire Bears |
| 2nd Base | Kevin Christorf | Stanley Slammers |
| 3rd Base | Jake Lindberg | Eau Claire Bears |
| Shortstop | Jim Thill | Eau Claire Bears |
| Outfield | Palmer Buss | Eau Claire Bears |
| Outfield | Ryan Freitag | Osseo Merchants |
| Outfield | Austin LeMay | Tilden Tigers |
| Utility | Scott Hovell | Whitehall Wolves |
| DH | Garret Nix | Osseo Merchants |
| Sportsmanship Award | Bloomer Woodticks | |
| Manager of the Year | Reed Pecha | Eau Claire Bears |
2014 Season
| Position | Name | Team |
| Pitcher | Alex Byom | Whitehall Wolves |
| Pitcher | Scott Horn | Stanley Slammers |
| Pitcher | Chevy Tollefson | Eau Claire Bears |
| Catcher | Max Ferguson | Whitehall Wolves |
| 1st Base | Tom Mewhorter | Eau Claire Bears |
| 2nd Base | Corey Poirer | Bloomer Woodticks |
| 3rd Base | Josh Anderson | Osseo Merchants |
| Shortstop | Jesse Brockman | Osseo Merchants |
| Outfield | Ryan Fretiag | Osseo Merchants |
| Outfield | Austin LeMay | Tilden Tigers |
| Outfield | Jon Schoch | Tilden Tigers |
| Utility | Randy Gustafson | Stanley Slammers |
| DH | Chad Fjelstad | Beef River Bullfrogs |
| Sportsmanship Award | Bloomer Woodticks | |
| Manager of the Year | Ryan Baier | Tilden Tigers |
2013 Season
| Position | Name | Team |
| Pitcher | Alex Byom | Whitehall Wolves |
| Pitcher | Tyler Gray | Chippewa Falls Lumberjacks |
| Pitcher | Kyle Pronchinske | Whitehall Wolves |
| Catcher | Andy Niese | Chippewa Falls Lumberjacks |
| 1st Base | Tom Mewhorter | Eau Claire Bears |
| 2nd Base | Brian Menard | Eau Claire Bears |
| 3rd Base | Nate Larson | Hallie Eagles |
| Shortstop | Nolan Fadness | Beef River Bullfrogs |
| Outfield | Adam DeWolf | Hallie Eagles |
| Outfield | Ryan Freitag | Osseo Merchants |
| Outfield | Austin LeMay | Chipppea Falls Lumberjacks |
| Utility | Curtis Dachel | Bloomer Woodticks |
| DH | Adam Cordova | Whitehall Wolves |
| Sportsmanship Award | Bloomer Woodticks | |
| Manager of the Year | Ben Pitsch | Jim Falls Sturgeons |
2012 Season
| Position | Name | Team |
| Pitcher | Cody Bunkelman | Jim Falls Sturgeons |
| Pitcher | Chevy Tollefson | Eau Claire Bears |
| Pitcher | Klye Pronchinske | Whitehall Wolves |
| Catcher | Max Ferguson | Whitehall Wolves |
| 1st Base | Tom Mewhorter | Eau Claire Bears |
| 2nd Base | Jeremy Nicolai | Eau Claire Bears |
| 3rd Base | Josh Anderson | Osseo Merchants |
| Shortshop | Tyler Manley | Whitehall Wolves |
| Outfield | Emery Hull | Chippewa Falls Lumberjacks |
| Outfield | Todd Lasher | Beef River Bullfrogs |
| Outfield | Brad Schank | Whitehall Wolves |
| Utility | Luke Short | Tilden Tigers |
| DH | Ben Pitsch | Jim Falls Sturgeons |
| Sportsmanship Award | Bloomer Woodticks | |
| Manager of the Year | Luke Anderson | Osseo Merchants |
2011 Season
| Position | Name | Team |
| Pitcher | Tyler Gray | Chippewa Falls Lumberjacks |
| Pitcher | Adam Rothenbuhler | Beef River Bullfrogs |
| Pitcher | Andrew Ruf | Tilden Tigers |
| Catcher | Max Ferguson | Whitehall Wolves |
| 1st Base | Justin Boiteau | Jim Falls Strugeons |
| 2nd Base | Josh Briggs | Chippewa Falls Lumberjacks |
| 3rd Base | Nate Larson | Hallie Eagles |
| Shortshop | Tyler Manley | Whitehall Wolves |
| Outfield | Nate Liedl | Jim Falls Sturgeons |
| Outfield | Brian Menard | Eau Claire Bears |
| Outfield | Reed Pecha | Eau Claire Bears |
| Utility | Luke Short | Tilden Tigers |
| DH | Hans Soukup | Chippewa Falls Lumberjacks |
| Sportsmanship Award | Osseo Merchants | |
| Manager of the Year | Paul Pehler | Whitehall Wolves |
2010 Season
| Position | Name | Team |
| Pitcher | Tyler Gray | Chippewa Falls Lumberjacks |
| Pitcher | Matt Lunde | Eau Claire Bears |
| Pitcher | Kyle Pronschinske | Whitehall Wolves |
| Catcher | Max Ferguson | Whitehall Wolves |
| 1st Base | Brian Menard | Eau Claire Bears |
| 2nd Base* | Kevin Christorf | Augusta Athletics |
| 2nd Base* | Wes Stuckert | Blomer Woodticks |
| 3rd Base | Chad Fjelstad | Beef River Bullfrogs |
| Shortshop | Scott Wolfe | Eau Claire Bears |
| Outfield | Luke Merrit | Hallie Eagles |
| Outfield | Brad Schank | Whitehall Wolves |
| Outfield | Reed Pecha | Eau Claire Bears |
| Utility | Todd Bresina | Tilden Tigers |
| DH | Luke Stelter | Eau Claire Bears |
| Sportsmanship Award | Bloomer Woodticks | |
| Manager of the Year | Paul Pehler | Whitehall Wolves |
*Tie in voting