2009 Season
| Position | Name | Team |
| Pitcher | Adam Ferrell | Hallie Eagles |
| Pitcher | Matt Lunde | Eau Claire Bears |
| Pitcher | Garret Nix | Osseo Merchants |
| Catcher | Andy Niese | Chippewa Falls LUmberjacks |
| 1st Base | Justin Boiteau | Jim Falls Sturgeons |
| 2nd Base | Jim Thill | Eau Claire Bears |
| 3rd Base | Scott Gibson | Augusta Athletics |
| Shortshop | Mitch Steinmetz | Tilden Tigers |
| Outfield | Shane Dutton | Augusta Athletics |
| Outfield | Brian Menard | Eau Claire Bears |
| Outfield | Reed Pecha | Eau Claire Bears |
| Utility | Chad Fjelstad | Beef River Bullfrogs |
| DH | Hans Soukup | Chippea Falls Lumberjacks |
| Sportsmanship Award | Jim Falls Sturgeons | |
| Manager of the Year | Luke Walker | Hallie Eagles |
2008 Season
| Position | Name | Team |
| Pitcher | Tyler Gray | Chippewa Falls Lumberjacks |
| Pitcher | Jon Huth | Eau Claire Bears |
| Pitcher | Andrew Ruf | Tilden Tigers |
| Catcher | Andy Niese | Chippewa Falls Lumberjacks |
| 1st Base | Justin Boiteau | Jim Falls Sturgeons |
| 2nd Base | Paul Henrichs | Augusta Athletics |
| 3rd Base* | Nate Larson | Eau Claire Bears |
| 3rd Base* | Lance Watkins | Beef River Bullfrogs |
| Shortstop | Chad Fjelstad | Beef River Bullfrogs |
| Outfield | Todd Lasher | Beef River Bullfrogs |
| Outfield | Reed Pecha | Eau Claire Bears |
| Outfield | Paul Pehler | Whitehall Wolves |
| Utility | Ben Morrison | Augusta Athletics |
| DH | Hans Soukup | Chippewa Falls Lumberjacks |
| Sportsmanship Award | Chippewa Falls Lumbejacks | |
| Manager of the Year | Andy Niese | Chippewa Falls Lumberjacks |
*Tie in voting
2007 Season
| Position | Name | Team |
| Pitcher | Jon Huth | Eau Claire Bears |
| Pitcher | Matt Lunde | Eau Claire Bears |
| Pitcher | Matt Simonson | Bloomer Woodticks |
| Catcher | Andy Niese | Chippewa Falls Lumberjacks |
| 1st Base | Ben Morrison | Augusta Athletics |
| 2nd Base* | Paul Henrichs | Augusta Athletics |
| 2nd Base* | Jim Thill | Eau Claire Bears |
| 3rd Base | Craig Frenette | Tilden Tigers |
| Shortshop | Scott Wolfe | Eau Claire Bears |
| Outfield | Todd Lasher | Beef River Bullfrogs |
| Outfield | Brandon Scheidler | Tilden Tigers |
| Outfield | Hans Soukup | Chippewa Falls Lumberjacks |
| Utility | Brad Barneson | Beef River Bullfrogs |
| DH | Nick Blair | Tilden Tigers |
| Sportsmanship Award | Jim Falls Sturgeons | |
| Manager of the Year | Scott Stuckert | Bloomer Woodticks |
*Tie in voting
2006 Season
| Position | Name | Team |
| Pitcher | Todd Bresina | Tilden Tigers |
| Pitcher | Jon Huth | Eau Claire Bears |
| Pitcher | Matt Lunde | Eau Claire Bears |
| Catcher | Andy Niese | Chippewa Falls Lumberjacks |
| 1st Base | Jeremiah Paulson | Augusta Athletics |
| 2nd Base | Jim Thill | Eau Claire Bears |
| 3rd Base | Scott Gibson | Augusta Athletics |
| Shortshop | Scott Wolfe | Eau Claire Bears |
| Outfield | Shane Dutton | Augusta Athletics |
| Outfield | Todd Lasher | Beef River Bullfrogs |
| Outfield | Chris Scheidler | Tilden Tigers |
| Utility | Duane Ives | Augusta Athletics |
| DH | Nick Blair | Tilden Tigers |
| Sportsmanship Award | Osseo Merchants | |
| Manager of the Year* | Scott Biederman | Eau Claire Bears |
| Manager of the Year* | Scott Sorenson | Augusta Athletics |
*Tie in voting
2005 Season
| Position | Name | Team |
| Pitcher | Brandon Bosher | Beef River Bullfrogs |
| Pitcher | Todd Bresina | Tilden Tigers |
| Pitcher | Jon Huth | Eau Claire Bears |
| Catcher | Andy Niese | Chippewa Falls Lumberjacks |
| 1st Base | Jeremiah Paulson | Augusta Athletics |
| 2nd Base | Jim Thill | Eau Claire Bears |
| 3rd Base | Mike Thompson | Bloomer Woodticks |
| Shortshop | Matt Miller | Beef River Bullfrogs |
| Outfield | Josh Briggs | Chippea Falls Lumberjacks |
| Outfield | Chad Fjelstad | Beef River Bullfrogs |
| Outfield | Matt Schmick | Jim Falls Sturgeons |
| Utility* | Pat Hawker | Augusta Athletics |
| Utility* | Todd Lasher | Beef River Bullfrogs |
| DH | Luke Short | Bloomer Woodticks |
| Sportsmanship Award | Jim Falls Sturgoens | |
| Manager of the Year | Jeremiah Paulson | Augusta Athletics |
*Tie in voting
2004 Season
| Position | Name | Team |
| Pitcher | Nick Blair | Tilden Tigers |
| Pitcher | Todd Bresina | Tilden Tigers |
| Pitcher | Justin Kunferman | Eau Claire Bears |
| Catcher | Joe Marquart | Jim Falls Sturgeons |
| 1st Base* | Randy Baier | Tilden Tigers |
| 1st Base* | Jeremiah Paulson | Augusta Athletics |
| 2nd Base | Brian Menard | Eau Claire Bears |
| 3rd Base | Scott Wolfe | Eau Claire Bears |
| Shortshop | Jason Denzer | Augusta Athletics |
| Outfield | Shane Dutton | Augusta Athletics |
| Outfield | Todd Lasher | Beef River Bullfrogs |
| Outfield | Luke McDonell | Tilden Tigers |
| Utility | Reed Pecha | Eau Claire Bears |
| DH | Chuck Hall | Chippewa Falls Lumberjacks |
| Sportsmanship Award | Osseo Merchants |
*Tie in voting
2003 Season
| Position | Name | Team |
| Pitcher | Matt Lunde | Eau Claire Bears |
| Pitcher | Todd Bresina | Tilden Tigers |
| Pitcher | Matt Simonson | Bloomer Woodticks |
| Catcher | Andy Niese | Chippewa Falls Lumbejacks |
| 1st Base | Brad Barneson | Beef River Bullfrogs |
| 2nd Base | Brian Menard | Eau Claire Bears |
| 3rd Base | Scott Wolfe | Eau Claire Bears |
| Shortshop | Mitch Steinmetz | Tilden Tigers |
| Outfield | Shane Dutton | Augusta Athletics |
| Outfield | Justin Boiteau | Jim Falls Sturgeons |
| Outfield | Ben Morrison | Augusta Athletics |
| Utility | Nick Blair | Tilden Tigers |
| DH | Nate Liedl | Jim Falls Sturgeons |
| Sportsmanship Award | Jim Falls Sturgeons |
2002 Season
| Position | Name | Team |
| Pitcher | Nick Blair | Tilden Tigers |
| Pitcher | Scott Hughes | Augusta Athletics |
| Pitcher | Kurt Stellpflug | Osseo Merchants |
| Catcher | Cory Martens | Bloomer Woodticks |
| 1st Base | Jeremiah Paulson | Augusta Athletics |
| 2nd Base* | Chad Fjelstad | Beef River Bullfrogs |
| 2nd Base* | Jordan Hedrington | Chippewa Falls Lumberjacks |
| 3rd Base | Dusty Freitag | Osseo Merchants |
| Shortstop | Matt Miller | Beef River Bullfrogs |
| Outfield | Shane Dutton | Augusta Athletics |
| Outfield | Luke McDonell | Tilden Tigers |
| Outfield | Brian Schroeder | Chippewa Falls Lumberjacks |
| DH | Jay Burian | Eau Claire Bears |
| Utility* | Brad Barneson | Beef River Bullfrogs |
| Utility* | Ben Morrison | Augusta Athletics |
| Sportsmanship Award | Chippewa Falls Lumberjacks |
2001 Season
| Position | Name | Team |
| Pitcher | Steve Fetterly | Chippewa Falls Lumberjacks |
| Pitcher | Jonathan Holt | Beef River Bullfrogs |
| Pitcher | Kurt Stellpflug | Osseo Merchants |
| Catcher | Andy Niese | Chippewa Falls Lumberjacks |
| 1st Base | Chester Janke | Osseo Merchants |
| 2nd Base | Chad Zutter | Hallie Eagles |
| 3rd Base | Scott Wolfe | Eau Claire Bears |
| Shortstop | Josh Felmlee | Hallie Eagles |
| Outfield | Marcelino Alonso | Augusta Athletics |
| Outfield | Shane Dutton | Augusta Athletics |
| Outfield | Jon Gardow | Tilden Tigers |
| DH | Tom Seaholm | Hallie Eagles |
| Utility | Brad Barneson | Beef River Bullfrogs |
| Sportsmanship Award | Hallie Eagles |
2000 Season
| Position | Name | Team |
| Pitcher | Nick Blair | Tilden Tigers |
| Pitcher | Andy Buck | Chippewa Falls Lumberjacks |
| Catcher | Lucas Chase | Osseo Merchants |
| 1st Base | Jeremiah Paulson | Augusta Athletics |
| 2nd Base | Jordan Hedrington | Chippewa Falls Lumberjacks |
| 3rd Base | Dusty Freitag | Osseo Merchants |
| Shortstop | Jonathan Holt | Beef River Bullfrogs |
| Outfield | Marcelino Alonso | Augusta Athletics |
| Outfield | Shane Dutton | Augusta Athletics |
| Outfield | Brad Sarauer | Hallie Eagles |
| DH | Tom Seaholm* | Hallie Eagles |
| Utility | Kurt Stellpflug | Augusta Athletics |
| Sportsmanship Award | Hallie Eagles |