2024 Season
| Position | Name | Team |
| Pitcher | Tyson Lucas | Chippewa Falls LumberJacks |
| Pitcher | Luke Eide* | Osseo Merchants |
| Pitcher | Zack Thiesse | Cadott Red Sox |
| Catcher | Sam Knickerbocker | Eau Claire Cavaliers |
| 1st Base | Cole Zwiefelhofer | Tilden Tigers |
| 2nd Base | Jack Kein | Cadott Red Sox |
| 3rd Base | Tyler Plitzner | Eau Claire Bears |
| Shortstop | Mason Tester | Jim Falls Sturgeons |
| Outfield | CJ Varsho | Chippewa Falls LumberJacks |
| Outfield | Lucas Steinmetz | Tilden Tigers |
| Outfield | Drew Saylers | Eau Claire Bears |
| Utility | Hunter Guenther | Eau Claire Bears |
| DH | Ryan Freitag | Osseo Merchants |
| MVP | Luke Eide | Osseo Merchants |
| ROY | Drew Saylers | Eau Claire Bears |
| Sportsmanship Award | Bloomer Woodticks | |
| Manager of the Year | Aaron Hagberg | Osseo Merchants |
| Pitcher of the Year** | Luke Eide | Osseo Merchants |
2023 Season
| Position | Name | Team |
| Pitcher | Quintin Gonzalez | Eau Claire Bears |
| Pitcher | Luke Eide* | Osseo Merchants |
| Pitcher | Lucas Costley | Eau Claire Cavaliers |
| Catcher | Bobby Soran | Jim Falls Sturgeons |
| 1st Base | Blake Johnson | Eau Claire Bears |
| 2nd Base | Caden Erickson | Eau Claire Cavaliers |
| 3rd Base | Gabe Richardson* | Osseo Merchants |
| Shortstop | Nolan Hutzler* | Chippewa Falls LumberJacks |
| Outfield | Jack Bowe | Chippewa Falls LumberJacks |
| Outfield | Jaxon Kostka | Osseo Merchants |
| Outfield | Tanner Halvorson* | Tilden Tigers |
| Utility | PJ Lequia | Tilden Tigers |
| DH | Ryan Freitag* | Osseo Merchants |
| MVP | Tanner Halvorson | Tilden Tigers |
| ROY | Henry Wilkinson | Cadott Red Sox |
| Sportsmanship Award | Bloomer Woodticks | |
| Manager of the Year | Rick Danielson | Cadott Red Sox |
| Pitcher of the Year** | Luke Eide | Osseo Merchants |
2022 Season
| Position | Name | Team |
| Pitcher | Joel Zachow | Eau Claire Bears |
| Pitcher | PJ LeQuia* | Tilden Tigers |
| Pitcher | Luke Eide | Osseo Merchants |
| Catcher | Todd Wienkes | Osseo Merchants |
| 1st Base | Cooper Kapanke | Eau Claire Cavaliers |
| 2nd Base | Matt Martineau* | Chippewa Falls LumberJacks |
| 3rd Base | Zach Merrit | Cadott Red Sox |
| Shortstop | Drew Steinmetz | Tilden Tigers |
| Outfield | Lance Letter | Eau Claire Rivermen |
| Outfield | Todd Lasher | Eau Claire Bears |
| Outfield | Jordan Steinmetz* | Tilden Tigers |
| Utility | Noah Hanson | Tilden Tigers |
| DH | Andy Niese | Eau Claire Rivermen |
| MVP | Jordan Steinmetz | Tilden Tigers |
| ROY | Will Jacobson | Jim Falls Sturgeons |
| Sportsmanship Award | Cadott Red Sox | |
| Manager of the Year | Peter Thaler | Jim Falls Sturgeons |
2021 Season
| Position | Name | Team |
| Pitcher | Luke Eide* | Osseo Merchants |
| Pitcher | Curtis Dachel | Bloomer Woodticks |
| Pitcher | Levi Schaller | Chippewa Falls LumberJacks |
| Catcher | Nolan Hutzler | Chippewa Falls LumberJacks |
| 1st Base | Nate Hayes | Chippewa Falls LumberJacks |
| 2nd Base | Nathan Kent* | Eau Claire Bears |
| 3rd Base | Nolan Baier* | Tilden Tigers |
| Shortstop | Jesse Brockman | Osseo Merchants |
| Outfield | Mitch Voller | Eau Claire Cavaliers |
| Outfield | Jordan Steinmetz | Tilden Tigers |
| Outfield | Jon Schoch | Tilden Tigers |
| Utility | Tyler Gray | Eau Claire Rivermen |
| DH | Nolan Matson* | Osseo Merchants |
| MVP | Luke Eide | Osseo Merchants |
| ROY | Mitch Voller | Eau Claire Cavaliers |
| Sportsmanship Award | Cadott Red Sox | |
| Manager of the Year | Luke Anderson | Osseo Merchants |
2020 Season
All-CRBL Awards were not selected as regular season was cancelled due to COVID-19 concerns.